Why a Cyber Insurance Claim is not just a “Glorified Business Interruption claim.”

Cyber Insurance Claim

An important insight following a recent cyber insurance CEC claim review

 

The Dangerous Trap of “Silent” Parallelism

To the untrained eye, a cyber business interruption (BI) claim looks identical to a traditional property BI claim: the business stops trading, revenue drops, and expenses pile up. It is tempting for brokers to view cyber cover as simply an extension of standard business continuity packages. However, treating cyber as “glorified BI” is a fundamental misdiagnosis that could leave a business severely exposed. While traditional BI relies on physical, visible triggers like fire or flood damage, cyber describes a myriad of invisible, malicious, and fluid ways a business can be damaged.

The Loss Adjusters Perspective: Where the Claims Fight is Won and Lost

As CEC act exclusively for the policyholder, we see first-hand where standard BI thinking crumbles during a cyber incident. Brokers must prepare their clients for three structural challenges unique to digital losses:

  • The Forensic Catch-22: In a fire claim, the damage is self-evident. In a cyber claim, the damage cannot be seen – but still the burden of proof is heavily on the policyholder. Insurers require definitive forensic evidence to quantify financial loss. Yet, if the policyholder’s servers are disabled by the attack or seized for analysis, extracting clean financial, payroll, or supply chain data becomes an operational paradox.
  • The Exploding Cost of Working: Traditional Increased Cost of Working (ICW) covers the extra cost of hiring replacement equipment or premises. Cyber ICW involves emergency day-rates for external (or internal) IT remediation teams, rapid cloud architecture deployment, and massive manual data-entry overtime to reconstruct corrupted records. The policy will almost certainly cover the repairs to the systems – and maybe even the costs of inserting protections to ensure the problem is avoided in the future – but not those “soft costs” that are incurred as extra working expenses.
  • The Trust Deficit: When a factory burns down, customers may wait out of loyalty, but there is a stigma attached to cyber. When a network is breached, customers flee out of fear for their own data. Restoring “digital trust” is a prolonged marketing and PR expense that some traditional BI loss assessment methods simply do not recognise.

The Broker’s Imperative

Brokers have done the work to identify the most appropriate cover and explained the need for it to their clients. They know it must have extended indemnity periods that reflect systemic and business operational realities, not just server downtime. In the event of a claim those clients will need assistance from independent financial loss experts to quantify the effects (long and short term) and extra costs the business has suffered. When dealing with an invisible peril, relying solely on an insurer’s panel of forensic accountants to do this is a risk no commercial business can afford to take.

Please contact CEC for more information regarding cyber insurance claims and how we can support you through the claims process.